The Business Advisory Blog

The Business Advisory Blog

Insight, news and updates from Alliott NZ Chartered Accountants, Auckland New Zealand. The views expressed here are the views of the author and should be discussed in further detail should an article be relevant to your individual circumstances.

While every effort has been made to provide valuable, useful information in this publication, this firm and any related suppliers or associated companies accept no responsibility or any form of liability from reliance upon or use of its contents. Any suggestions should be considered carefully within your own particular circumstances, as they are intended as general information only.

Michael Beech
Published on

Many people have taken advantage of the coronavirus lockdown to learn new skills

From baking bread, to knitting, to learning a language... but trading securities is possibly not something you should do without professional advice.

BakingcookiewithdadThe danger of attempting to ‘play’ the market through short-term trading and timing strategies was highlighted recently in a warning to retail investors by the Australian market watchdog the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). [1]

The regulator said its own analysis of securities markets during the COVID-19 lockdown had revealed a substantial increase in activity by retail investors or ‘day traders’—people using now easily accessible software and trading tools to try to time the market.

Not only had trading frequency increased rapidly during the pandemic, but the duration of people holding securities had fallen significantly. In short, it looks like folks in isolation at home have been trying to generate quick windfalls from market volatility.

“Even market professionals find it hard to ‘time’ the market in a turbulent environment, and the risk of significant losses is a regular challenge,” ASIC said. “For retail investors to attempt the same is particularly dangerous, and likely to lead to heavy losses—losses that could not happen at a worse time for many families.”

Of course, a common reaction to these sorts of warnings is for people to say to themselves: “It’s true there are a lot of naïve day traders out there with no experience. But the difference is that I’m extra careful and I know what I’m doing.”

Unfortunately, there is little evidence that there is a burgeoning industry of successful home-based stock traders out there.

ASIC says its analysis found retail investors chasing quick profits traditionally perform poorly in good times and bad and even in relatively stable, less volatile market conditions.

Using its market surveillance data based on trading through retail brokers, ASIC focused on activity in the period from 24 February to 3 April 2020.

It found that on more than two thirds of the days on which retail investors were net buyers in this period, the prices of their targeted shares declined the next day. Conversely, the study found that on days in this period where retail investors were net sellers, the shares they sold more likely increased the next day.

In other words, the regulator says its detailed research over this focus period found little evidence that home-bound DIY traders were proficient in predicting short-term market movements, either on the way down or the way up.

“While markets generally recover over the long run and tend to grow with economic fundamentals, short-term trading and poor market timing can be a major risk for investors in volatile markets,” ASIC said. “Therefore, retail investors should be wary of trying to ‘play the market’ for short-term price movements by day trading.”

Furthermore, the regulator warned that the probability and impact of unpredictable news and events in offshore markets overnight only magnified this danger.

In previous statements, ASIC has said while some people may be drawn to the sense of control they feel in investing for themselves and the opportunity to save money, the risk is that they overrate their own expertise and fail to diversify sufficiently.

“A financial advisor can help you set financial goals, understand your risk tolerance and find the right investments,” the regulator says on its popular ‘MoneySmart’ site.

In summary, while the COVID-19 isolation period has encouraged many of us to become more self-sufficient, do-it-yourself share trading should probably be viewed the same as DIY electrical work – whilst it may be possible to rewire the house yourself is it really worth the risk and will you sleep easy at night?

Global financial markets are highly competitive and full of smart people with sophisticated trading and analytical tools. News is quickly built into prices. While some amateurs may feel they have an edge, there is little evidence that this is the case.

Rather than trying to generate quick profits through trading, a better approach is to think about your long term goals and build a diversified portfolio aimed at achieving them—a portfolio that is made for you and that allows you to sleep at night.

Michael Beech CFA is an experienced investment specialist and is responsible for providing investment advice as well as managing the investment portfolios for many of Alliott NZ's clients. Click here to read more or call Alliotts in Auckland on 09 520 9200 for an introduction to Michael.

[1] ‘Retail Investors at Risk in Volatile Markets’, ASIC, 6 May 2020.